Researcher Points to Four Reasons
The American Gaming Association (AGA) has opened up a can of worms with a study
that it recently commissioned concerning the social costs associated with
problem gambling (whether at the land or online casinos). The white paper that
resulted from the paper has led to a flurry of media attention and many land and
online casinos are looking for vindication for the bad reputation that they have
in many circles because so many opponents site the high social costs related to
allowing gambling activities in a society.
Dr. Douglas M. Walker is a professor of economics at Charleston College, and was
commissioned by the AGA to look into social costs associated with problem or
pathological gamblers. The AGA represents the interests of much of the land
gambling industry in the United States (online casinos are still banned in the
U.S. and subsequently have no large scale interest group). Walker’s white paper
was posted on the AGA Web site, and within a short time was making national news
with it’s simple yet valid assertion that past estimations of social costs
associated with problem gambling did not take into consideration four main flaws
in the research.
Walker points to four basic research related issues that have never before been
blatantly addressed in relation to problem gambling research:
• Survey data validity
• Comorbidity, discussed in depth here:
• Measurement of government expenditures related problem gambling treatments and
programs
• The counterfactual scenario, or more specifically, the estimate of societal
effects if legalized gambling had never occurred
The research study certainly has some valid points, and though the mainstream
media has picked up on the issue and blown up the implications associated with
invalidating past estimations of social costs, the AGA has much more humble
expectations for the white paper. The President and Chief Executive for the
American Gaming Association, Frank Fahrenkopf Jr, remarks that “These are
complex issues that don’t have easy answers but the methodological issues
outlined in this paper must be addressed by researchers in order for
policymakers and voters to have a meaningful debate about social costs
attributable to gambling.” The AGA is merely hoping that the white paper will
add a new perspective to future discussions related to problem gambling at the
land and online casinos.
|